Evaluating an SEO provider
A PRACTICAL DECISION GUIDE

RegalSEO alternative: how to choose between an agency and a freelance SEO

If you're looking at RegalSEO, you're probably comparing a few providers and trying to work out which one will actually move your rankings. I haven't worked with RegalSEO and I can't speak to their service — so this page doesn't try to. Instead, it gives you a practical way to evaluate any SEO provider, including me.

I'm Saqib, an independent SEO specialist working with businesses in the US, UK, Australia and Europe since 2019. If you want a direct, one-person option to put on your shortlist, this page shows what that looks like.

THE HONEST PICTURE

Agency or freelancer: an honest look at both

Where agencies are usually stronger

  • More people, so more capacity and more disciplines under one roof.
  • Continuity if a staff member leaves.
  • Established processes and formal contracts, which some companies require.

Where a specialist is usually stronger

  • The person who sells you the work is the person who does it.
  • Faster decisions and changes, often the same day.
  • More of your budget goes to SEO work rather than overhead.
  • Flexible scope: an audit, a one-off project, or a monthly retainer.

The honest part: where a specialist is weaker

  • Limited capacity. One person can only serve a small number of clients well.
  • Single point of failure: if I'm unavailable, work slows down.
  • Narrower scope: I don't run paid ads, branding or video.

Neither model wins in every case. What matters is which one matches your situation.

SEO provider evaluation checklist
USE IT ON EVERYONE

The 7-point checklist for choosing any SEO provider

Use these questions with RegalSEO, with me, and with anyone else on your list. They're the same questions I'd want you to ask me — a good provider welcomes all seven.

And watch for the red flags: guaranteed rankings or “page one in 30 days,” refusing to explain what they do, pressure to sign a long contract before showing any work, vague answers about who does the work, or reports with no explanation of what was actually done.

1

Who will actually do the work?

Ask for names and roles, not “our team.” If the person you meet on the sales call won't be doing the work, find out who will.

2

Can I see a real sample report?

A good provider can show a redacted report that explains what changed, why, and what happens next. Be wary of reports that are only screenshots of ranking tools.

3

Can I speak to a current or past client?

References should be real and reachable. Case studies with numbers and timeframes are a good second-best.

4

What exactly am I paying for each month?

Ask for a written scope: audits, content pieces, links, hours. Vague packages are hard to hold anyone to.

5

What happens if I cancel?

Look for the notice period, any minimum term, and whether you keep the work, access and documentation.

6

How do you build links?

Ask for the method and examples. Anyone who says “guaranteed links” or is vague about sources is a risk. Poor link building can hurt your site.

7

How will we measure success?

Agree on the goals up front: leads, revenue and qualified traffic, not just rankings. Ask how long results usually take. Honest answers are measured in months, not weeks.

Direct answers from your SEO specialist
MY ANSWERS, PLAINLY

How I answer those seven questions

  • Who does the work? Me, personally. Every audit, fix and outreach.
  • Sample report? Here's a real one, redacted — or I'll walk you through one on a call.
  • References? Real buyer reviews below, and I'm happy to connect you with a client.
  • What you pay for? A written scope agreed before we start: one flat plan, $700/month.
  • Cancellation? Month to month. You keep everything: all work, documentation and access.
  • Link building? White-hat outreach to relevant sites. No PBNs, no purchased spam links.
  • Measurement? Goals set at the start, with plain-English monthly reporting on what moved and what's next.
MAKE IT OBJECTIVE

A simple way to score your options

Score each provider from 1 to 5 on the seven questions above and total them. Weight the points that matter most to you — a small business may care most about who does the work and cancellation terms, while an enterprise may care most about capacity and references.

1. Who does the work
2. Sample report quality
3. Reachable references
4. Written monthly scope
5. Fair cancellation terms
6. Honest link building
7. Clear success metrics

If a provider scores poorly on more than two, keep looking — whichever model they use.

PROOF, NOT PROMISES

See a real sample report

This is a real monthly report I sent a client — with the client's name, domain and private document links redacted. It shows the work log, PageSpeed before-and-after screenshots, content output, and a metric table comparing month over month.

  • 15 work items documented, each with what was done and why
  • Core Web Vitals and PageSpeed screenshots as proof
  • Organic traffic +40.1% and keywords +2.1% that month, with dashboard evidence
Open the sample report (PDF)

What a good report looks like

It explains what changed, why it changed, and what happens next — in words you can understand. If a provider's “report” is only screenshots of a ranking tool with no explanation of the work behind the numbers, that's a red flag (see checklist point 2).

You'd receive this exact format every month: a written work log plus metric tables, so you always know what your $700 bought.

CLIENT FEEDBACK

What clients say

Real reviews from Fiverr, shown verbatim.

“Amazing quality in his work exactly what I asked for could not be happier. I love working with saqib so open and honest pricing is fair and takes on each job I set with sheer honesty and integrity. Thanks you for your help saqib!”
UN
uniqautosukFiverr buyer · United Kingdom
“Did a great job. The first approach didnt work but after some great tweaking it worked better than ever before.”
BE
bendemenFiverr buyer · Netherlands
“I recently worked with Saqib to resolve a CSS bug on my website, and I couldn't be happier with the results. He was incredibly technical and demonstrated a deep understanding of the issue.”
SE
seogorillasFiverr buyer · Canada
FIT CHECK

Who I'm a good fit for

Good fit

  • Small and mid-sized businesses, ecommerce stores and service companies.
  • Businesses with one main market that want senior attention on SEO.
  • Owners who want a direct line to the person doing the work.

Probably not a fit

  • Companies that need a large team, a paid media program or formal procurement.
  • Projects that need several languages and markets managed at once.

If you're not a fit, I'll tell you and point you to someone who might be.

PRICING

One plan. One price.

Full SEO, done monthly by one senior specialist — $700/month, flat.

  • On-page SEO
  • Technical SEO
  • Off-page SEO
  • Partnership links continue after month three
  • Local SEO for one area or city
  • AI SEO: AEO, GEO and AISO
  • Monthly report
  • Direct WhatsApp or the client's preferred platform
Start with a free review
FAQS

RegalSEO alternative questions you’re probably asking.

No. I haven’t worked with them, and I’m not judging their service. This page helps you compare any providers on the same criteria.
For many small and mid-sized businesses focused on one market, yes. For large, multi-market or multi-channel programs, an agency is often the better choice.
I also build WordPress and Shopify websites. For paid ads, branding or video, I’ll refer you to someone reliable.
SEO usually takes several months to show meaningful movement, depending on competition and your site’s starting point. I’ll give you a realistic timeline after the free review.
One plan: $700 per month, flat. It covers on-page SEO, technical SEO, off-page SEO, local SEO for one area or city, AI SEO (AEO, GEO, AISO), a monthly report, and direct WhatsApp access. Month to month — no long contract.
Let's talk

Want a second opinion before you decide?

Send me your site and I'll give you a free review, including what I'd fix first. You can use it whichever provider you end up choosing.